Skip to content
GoodVat

Stripe Tax vs Taxually for Cross-Border Sellers 2026

Stripe Tax and Taxually are not natural competitors — Stripe features Taxually as its recommended IOSS filing partner directly in the Stripe Tax section of the Dashboard. The two tools are designed to work together rather than replace each other: Stripe Tax handles checkout tax calculation, Taxually handles EU VAT compliance and filing. Understanding where one ends and the other begins is the whole point of this comparison.

For UK sellers who’ve activated Stripe Tax and are asking “but who files my IOSS return?”, the answer is often Taxually. For sellers evaluating EU compliance from scratch, the question is whether you need both, or just one.

1. Local VAT / Sales Tax Filing

Section titled “1. Local VAT / Sales Tax Filing”

Stripe Tax: Does not file UK VAT returns. Stripe Tax calculates UK VAT on Stripe-processed transactions and produces reports, but the MTD submission to HMRC happens in your accounting software — Xero, QuickBooks, FreeAgent, or similar. Stripe Tax is calculation infrastructure; filing is a separate step.

Taxually: Files UK VAT returns via MTD. Taxually is a licensed UK VAT agent and can submit MTD-compliant VAT returns to HMRC on your behalf. This is a genuine end-to-end service — Taxually imports your transaction data from connected platforms, prepares the VAT return, and submits it. For sellers who want to outsource UK VAT filing entirely rather than export data to accounting software and file manually, Taxually handles this.

Verdict: Taxually wins clearly. This is one of the core reasons UK cross-border sellers consider Taxually — it covers the filing step that Stripe Tax and most calculation tools deliberately leave to accounting software.

2. EU IOSS

Section titled “2. EU IOSS”

Stripe Tax: Native IOSS calculation. Once your IOSS number is entered in Stripe’s tax registration settings, Stripe automatically applies the correct destination-country VAT rate to EU orders under €150 and zero-rates orders above the threshold. Stripe Tax does not act as your IOSS intermediary and does not file your monthly IOSS return. For filing, Stripe points you directly to Taxually — “File with Taxually” links appear in the Stripe Tax section of the Dashboard.

Taxually: Acts as a registered IOSS intermediary. This is a distinct regulatory status — Taxually takes on the legal obligation for your IOSS registration with an EU member state, collects the monthly sales data, prepares the IOSS return, and remits VAT to the relevant EU tax authorities on your behalf. This is the service that calculation-only tools (Stripe Tax, Quaderno, Avalara) cannot provide.

Taxually also calculates destination-country VAT on IOSS-eligible orders across connected channels, not just Stripe transactions. For sellers using Shopify with Stripe, WooCommerce, Amazon, or Etsy, Taxually aggregates IOSS transaction data from all sources for a single monthly return.

Verdict: Taxually wins. Stripe Tax calculates but doesn’t file; Taxually does both. The two are designed to be used together — Stripe Tax for checkout calculation, Taxually for the monthly return — but if you want a single provider for both, Taxually covers the full IOSS obligation where Stripe Tax covers only half of it.

3. EU OSS

Section titled “3. EU OSS”

Stripe Tax: Supports EU OSS calculation. Non-Union OSS — the applicable scheme for international sellers of digital services to EU consumers — is covered. Stripe Tax applies destination-country VAT rates and produces country-level reports. Filing the OSS return is your responsibility; Stripe Tax does not submit it.

Taxually: Handles OSS filing. Taxually can register you for OSS in the appropriate member state, collect transaction data from connected platforms, prepare the quarterly OSS return, and submit it. For sellers who want EU OSS managed end-to-end rather than just the data to file it themselves, Taxually’s managed service covers this.

Verdict: Taxually wins on completeness. Both support OSS calculation. Taxually adds the managed filing step — the option to hand over the OSS obligation entirely rather than handle filing separately.

4. US Sales Tax

Section titled “4. US Sales Tax”

Stripe Tax: Strong US sales tax coverage. All US states, economic nexus tracking, address-level calculation, nexus threshold alerts, and US sales tax filing from the Stripe Dashboard via a TaxJar-powered integration. For UK sellers with meaningful US volume, this is a clean end-to-end solution.

Taxually: No US sales tax support. Taxually’s scope is EU VAT and UK VAT — it does not calculate or file US sales tax returns. If you sell to US customers, you need a separate solution for that side of the business.

Verdict: Stripe Tax wins decisively. For UK sellers shipping to the US as well as the EU, Taxually’s absence of US coverage is a significant gap. You would need Stripe Tax (or a separate US tool) alongside Taxually regardless.

5. VAT Calculation at Checkout

Section titled “5. VAT Calculation at Checkout”

Stripe Tax: Real-time tax calculation on every Stripe-processed transaction. Correct VAT rate by customer location and product type, EU VAT ID validation with automatic B2B reverse charge, automatic rate updates. Transactions outside Stripe are not covered.

Taxually: Taxually’s primary function is compliance and filing, not real-time checkout calculation. Taxually imports transaction data from connected platforms after sales occur — it is not a checkout tax engine in the way Stripe Tax or Avalara AvaTax is. It uses this imported data to prepare returns, not to calculate tax at the point of purchase.

This means Taxually does not directly replace Stripe Tax for checkout. A business using Taxually for EU VAT filing still needs a checkout calculation layer — typically Stripe Tax, Shopify Tax, or a WooCommerce plugin — to apply the correct VAT rate at the moment of purchase.

Verdict: Stripe Tax wins. This is not a close comparison — Taxually is not a checkout tax engine. This is why Stripe partners with Taxually rather than competing with it: they solve different parts of the same compliance problem.

6. Platform Integrations

Section titled “6. Platform Integrations”

Stripe Tax:

  • Shopify — via Stripe as payment processor
  • WooCommerce — via Stripe payments
  • Custom stores / APIs — single line of code, developer-friendly
  • Stripe Billing, Checkout, Invoicing, Payment Links — natively covered
  • Non-Stripe channels — not covered

Taxually:

  • Shopify — native app; imports transaction data for VAT reporting and filing regardless of payment processor
  • WooCommerce — integration for transaction import and VAT return preparation
  • Amazon — imports marketplace sales data for IOSS and VAT returns
  • eBay — imports marketplace transaction data
  • Etsy — supported for marketplace VAT data
  • Stripe — Taxually connects to Stripe as a data source, importing Stripe transaction data into Taxually’s compliance platform
  • Xero, QuickBooks — accounting integrations for data sync
  • Google Sheets — manual import option for sellers not on supported platforms

Taxually’s integrations are designed for data aggregation and return preparation, not real-time checkout calculation. The Shopify and WooCommerce integrations pull historical transaction data; they don’t sit in the checkout flow.

Verdict: Different purposes, different maps. Taxually’s multi-channel aggregation is useful for sellers on multiple platforms who need a single IOSS or OSS return covering all channels. Stripe Tax’s integrations are checkout-focused and Stripe-native. They complement rather than overlap.

7. Pricing Model

Section titled “7. Pricing Model”

Stripe Tax: 0.5% per transaction where tax is calculated and you’re registered to collect. No monthly fee, no setup fee, no contracts. Simple and proportional.

For a UK seller doing £6,000/month in EU sales: approximately £30/month in Stripe Tax fees.

Taxually: Subscription-based pricing with tiers based on annual turnover and the services included. Taxually’s pricing is not fully transparent on its public website — specific plans depend on which services you need (IOSS only, OSS + IOSS, UK MTD + EU, etc.) and your transaction volume. Published indicative pricing starts around €49–99/month for IOSS intermediary services for small sellers, scaling with turnover. UK VAT filing and OSS may be separate add-ons or included depending on the plan.

The pricing model reflects Taxually’s value: you’re paying for a managed compliance service (actual filing and regulatory responsibility) rather than just software access. That is a meaningfully different thing from Stripe Tax’s per-transaction calculation fee.

When used together — Stripe Tax for calculation, Taxually for filing — the combined cost is: Stripe Tax’s 0.5% per taxable transaction plus Taxually’s monthly subscription. For many UK cross-border sellers, this combined cost is still significantly below alternatives like Avalara, and the coverage is more complete than either tool alone.

Verdict: Stripe Tax is cheaper as a standalone calculation tool. Taxually charges a subscription for managed compliance services that Stripe Tax doesn’t provide. The right comparison is not Stripe Tax vs Taxually on price — it’s “Stripe Tax + Taxually” vs the cost of the compliance exposure of not filing your IOSS and OSS returns correctly.

8. Setup Complexity

Section titled “8. Setup Complexity”

Stripe Tax: Very low. Single toggle in the Stripe Dashboard. Adding registrations (IOSS number, OSS, UK VAT number, US states) takes minutes per jurisdiction.

Taxually: Low to moderate. Taxually’s onboarding involves creating an account, connecting your sales platforms (Shopify, WooCommerce, Amazon, etc.), and completing the IOSS or VAT registration process. For IOSS, Taxually handles the intermediary registration with an EU member state on your behalf — this takes a few days for the registration to be confirmed. Once set up, Taxually operates monthly (importing transaction data, preparing and submitting returns) with minimal manual input required.

For sellers new to EU compliance, Taxually’s onboarding process includes guidance on which obligations apply to your business — a useful starting point if you’re not sure whether you need IOSS, OSS, or local registrations.

Verdict: Stripe Tax is faster to activate. Taxually’s setup is more involved but appropriate to the service — you’re establishing a legal relationship as well as a software integration.

9. Reporting and Records

Section titled “9. Reporting and Records”

Stripe Tax: Location-specific tax reports per jurisdiction in the Stripe Dashboard, exportable as CSV. Good for feeding into accounting software or handing to an accountant. For EU IOSS’s 10-year record-keeping requirement, you’ll need to archive exports yourself.

Taxually: Compliance-grade records maintained within Taxually’s platform. Because Taxually is filing your returns, it retains the underlying transaction data, submitted returns, and confirmation receipts from tax authorities — the complete paper trail. For IOSS, where you must retain records for 10 years, Taxually’s retained records satisfy this obligation without you managing archives separately.

Taxually also provides visibility into filed returns and payment confirmations — useful for reconciling that VAT has actually been remitted to the correct EU authorities.

Verdict: Taxually wins on compliance-grade record-keeping. Because it files the returns, it holds the authoritative documentation. Stripe Tax’s exports are reports; Taxually’s records are a compliance archive.

10. Ecosystem / Wider Product

Section titled “10. Ecosystem / Wider Product”

Stripe Tax:

Stripe Tax sits within the Stripe payments ecosystem — Stripe Payments, Billing, Invoicing, Checkout, and Radar all live alongside it. The key ecosystem signal for this comparison: Stripe has explicitly integrated Taxually into the Stripe Tax Dashboard as its recommended partner for IOSS filing. “File with Taxually” links appear in the tax section for international sellers who have IOSS registrations. This is Stripe acknowledging the gap in its own product and pointing users to a specific solution.

Cross-border payment fee context: UK businesses paying EU cardholders via Stripe pay 2.5% + 20p per transaction post-Brexit.

Taxually:

Taxually’s product scope covers the EU VAT compliance lifecycle end-to-end: registration assistance, IOSS intermediary services, OSS filing, UK MTD filing, local EU VAT registrations, and VAT return preparation across multiple EU member states for sellers with local stock or registrations. For UK sellers expanding into EU markets who want to outsource the compliance function entirely, Taxually’s scope covers the obligations that sellers consistently find most burdensome — IOSS filing in particular.

Taxually also handles local EU VAT registrations when cross-border sellers need to register in individual member states (for example, sellers holding stock in an EU warehouse), which is beyond the scope of IOSS and OSS schemes.

Verdict: The ecosystems are genuinely complementary. Stripe’s ecosystem is payment-native; Taxually’s is compliance-native. The fact that Stripe surfaces Taxually within its own product is the clearest possible signal that these tools belong together rather than competing.

11. Support

Section titled “11. Support”

Stripe Tax: Excellent self-serve documentation for technical setup. Email and chat support for account issues. No dedicated tax advisory support — Stripe Tax will help you use the product, not advise on your obligations.

Taxually: Human support with VAT compliance expertise. Because Taxually is acting as your IOSS intermediary or VAT filing agent, its team necessarily has substantive EU VAT knowledge — they’re not just supporting software, they’re managing regulatory obligations. For sellers navigating EU VAT compliance questions (which scheme applies, which member state to register in, how to handle a tax authority query), Taxually’s team can provide substantive guidance where Stripe’s cannot.

Verdict: Taxually wins on compliance-specific support. Stripe Tax wins on technical documentation. For UK sellers managing EU VAT obligations, Taxually’s expertise is more directly relevant than Stripe’s developer-focused documentation.

12. Best For — The Honest Verdict

Section titled “12. Best For — The Honest Verdict”

Choose Stripe Tax if:

  • You process payments through Stripe and want VAT calculated automatically at checkout
  • You want US sales tax calculation and filing handled in one place
  • You’re comfortable managing EU VAT filing separately (via Taxually, an accountant, or an OSS portal)
  • You want zero-setup tax infrastructure for a Stripe-native store

Choose Taxually if:

  • You need an IOSS intermediary to file your monthly EU VAT return — Taxually is one of a small number of registered intermediaries that can do this
  • You want UK MTD VAT returns filed for you, not just calculated
  • You want EU OSS returns filed rather than just reported
  • You sell across multiple platforms (Shopify + Amazon + Etsy) and need a single IOSS return aggregating all channels
  • You want to outsource EU compliance rather than manage it internally

Use both if:

  • You’re on Stripe and need real-time checkout calculation (Stripe Tax) plus managed IOSS/OSS/UK MTD filing (Taxually)
  • This is the combination Stripe explicitly recommends and the most common setup for UK cross-border sellers already on Stripe

Neither if:

  • You need US sales tax — Taxually doesn’t cover this; add Stripe Tax or a dedicated US tool
  • You need a full e-commerce checkout tax engine outside Stripe — look at Quaderno or Avalara for multi-channel calculation

Quick Reference

Section titled “Quick Reference”
CriteriaStripe TaxTaxually
Local filing✗ Calculation only✓ Full MTD filing, licensed agent
EU IOSS calculation✓ Native, automatic✓ Multi-channel aggregation
EU IOSS filing✗ — recommends Taxually✓ Registered IOSS intermediary
EU OSS✓ Calculation + reports✓ Calculation + managed filing
US sales tax✓ Strong, Dashboard filing via TaxJar✗ Not covered
Checkout VAT calculation✓ Stripe transactions only✗ Compliance tool, not checkout engine
ShopifyVia Stripe payments✓ Native app, any payment processor
WooCommerceVia Stripe payments✓ Transaction import integration
Amazon / eBay / Etsy✗✓ Marketplace data import
Local EU VAT registrations✗✓
10-year IOSS record retentionSelf-managed exports✓ Retained in Taxually platform
Pricing0.5% per taxable transactionSubscription from ~€49–99/month; scales with volume
Setup complexityVery low — one toggleLow-moderate; includes IOSS registration
ReportingPer-jurisdiction CSV exportsCompliance-grade, filed-return records
SupportSelf-serve docsCompliance experts, VAT advisory
Recommended by Stripe—✓ Featured in Stripe Tax Dashboard
Best forStripe-native checkout calculation; US+EU sellersEU VAT filing; IOSS intermediary; UK MTD outsourcing
Section titled “Related Guides”